Rethink needed to move away from 'one-size-fits-all' approach on the Whole Farm Plan

The Scottish Crofting Federation has urged Scotland's Agriculture Jim Fairlie to make changes to the Whole Farm Plan which are 'proportionate' to the needs of crofters

clock • 2 min read
Scotting Crofting Federation chair Jonathan Hedges said: "We have repeatedly warned that disproportionate Whole Farm Plan measures will lead to crofters dropping out of the system – up until now, we have just not been listened to."
Image:

Scotting Crofting Federation chair Jonathan Hedges said: "We have repeatedly warned that disproportionate Whole Farm Plan measures will lead to crofters dropping out of the system – up until now, we have just not been listened to."

Crofters have warned there needs to be a rethink on a 'one-size-fits-all' model to the Whole Farm Plan.

Scottish Crofting Federation (SCF) chief executive Donna Smith confirmed Mr Fairlie has agreed to meet the organisation over the next few months to discuss how the Whole Farm Plan Requirements can be more 'proportionate' for crofters.

The Whole Farm Plan is a way of measuring the impact of a farm or croft and is a prerequisite to qualify for Basic Payments.

HAVE YOUR SAY: Take part in our tenant farming survey: 'How are changes to Inheritance Tax impacting your tenant farm?'

Scottish Government said the scheme aims to identify opportunities for farmers to improve sustainability and profitability in their business.

Farmers must complete two of five available audits before May 15 2025 to ensure they are paid; from a choice of a biodiversity audit, carbon audit, soil analysis, animal health and welfare plan, and an integrated pest management plan.

On Wednesday (February 19), the Scottish Parliament's Rural Affairs and Islands Committee discussed the statutory instrument that will make the Whole Farm Plan a legal requirement under Scottish law.

READ NOW: The Farmers Guardian Podcast: Scotland's new Tenant Farming Commissioner calls for more face-to-face conversations between tenants and landlords

SCF has warned the measure could lead to crofters 'being left behind' in the system and that there needs to be questions over the suitability of a 'universal' system which does not meet the needs of all crofters and producers in Scotland.

"We have repeatedly warned that disproportionate Whole Farm Plan measures will lead to crofters dropping out of the system – up until now, we have just not been listened to," SCF chair Jonathan Hedges said.

LISTEN NOW:

"However, we welcome Mr. Fairlie's invitation and are keen to discuss how we can make this work for crofters – but words must be followed by deeds."

Mr. Fairlie said he will listen to crofters' concerns and he hopes to build a constructive working relationship with the sector. 

And the Whole Farm Plan will ensure Scotland's agriculture sector is 'successful and sustainable' in the future, according to Scotland's Agriculture Minister.

READ NOW: What you need to know about bird flu

BNG National Habitat Bank Creation & Unit Sales

BNG National Habitat Bank Creation & Unit

VIEW ADVERT
£POA

Commercial Secured Bridging Loans for Business Purposes

Commercial Secured Bridging Loans for Business

VIEW ADVERT
£POA

FARM LOANS & RE-MORTGAGES

FARM LOANS & RE-MORTGAGES

VIEW ADVERT
£POA

More on Politics

Welsh farming and allied industries unite against Inheritance Tax changes at Royal Welsh Showground

Welsh farming and allied industries unite against Inheritance Tax changes at Royal Welsh Showground

NFU Cymru brought together farmers and representatives from rural businesses across mid-Wales for a display showcasing the far-reaching impact of the proposed changes to Inheritance Tax

Rachael Brown
clock 21 February 2025 • 4 min read
From the editor: The Government will not back down, but neither will farmers

From the editor: The Government will not back down, but neither will farmers

This week from Farmers Guardian editor Olivia Midgley

Olivia Midgley
clock 20 February 2025 • 2 min read
Efra chair to meet farmers and rural businesses at Royal Welsh showground to discuss IHT impact

Efra chair to meet farmers and rural businesses at Royal Welsh showground to discuss IHT impact

The event, organised by NFU Cymru Brecon and Radnor members, will involve a rally to demonstrate how the proposed changes to Inheritance Tax will impact the entire Welsh rural economy

Rachael Brown
clock 20 February 2025 • 2 min read