Sheep farmer James Rebanks turns down Defra role invite: "I cannot be complicit in the breaking of promises to farmers that I strongly believe ought to be kept"

Cumbrian sheep farmer and author James Rebanks reflects on his decision to turn down the invite to apply for a non-executive director at Defra

clock • 1 min read
Sheep farmer James Rebanks turns down Defra role invite: "I cannot be complicit in the breaking of promises to farmers that I strongly believe ought to be kept"

Cumbrian sheep farmer and author James Rebanks has turned down the invitation from Defra to apply for a non-executive director role at the Government department. 

By James Rebanks


"[I am] grateful to be asked, and that anyone there thinks I might be as asset. But as I said in my reply, I can't be complicit in the breaking of promises to farmers that I strong believe ought to be kept.

Defra

"As I tweeted last week, there is a shifting away from big commitments that I find deeply problematic. The level of budget declining. The chance of transition for most farms vanishing. The shift from public commitments to dodgy corporate money when we need more done and quick.

READ MORE: Financial consequences of bluetongue restrictions could see Suffolk farmer £50,000 out of pocket

"With those trends continuing and no commitment to do better, I can't sit round a table and act like it's OK. I'll happily help for free to make things work better, but I'm not prepared to be window dressing for decline and failure.

'Drifting away from us'

"And for the first time in my life I nearly said yes. I think we are within touching distance of a much better system and much better landscapes - but it's drifting away from us by the week.

READ ALSO: Defra's £358 million underspend of agriculture budget 'kick in the teeth' for farmers

"But a board member is partly responsible for what's done. So you have to believe you'd get a decent hearing and a chance of impact. Otherwise I may as well stay independent and be a mostly constructive critic."

 

 

FARM LOANS & RE-MORTGAGES

FARM LOANS & RE-MORTGAGES

VIEW ADVERT
£POA

BNG National Habitat Bank Creation & Unit Sales

BNG National Habitat Bank Creation & Unit

VIEW ADVERT
£POA

WATER ABSTRACTION LICENCES FOR SALE

WATER ABSTRACTION LICENCES FOR SALE

VIEW ADVERT
£POA

More on Blogs

Road to regen: Silas Hedley-Lawrence - "Nature wants to do the hard work for us, we just need to get out of her way"

Road to regen: Silas Hedley-Lawrence - "Nature wants to do the hard work for us, we just need to get out of her way"

Silas Hedley–Lawrence is a farmer, coach and consultant with a decade of hands-on experience in regenerative agriculture. With a background rooted in both commercial and direct selling models, he champions lean, profitable farming systems that increase biodiversity and soil health. Silas is an Integrity Soils trained agroecological coach from the Yellowstone 2024 cohort

Silas Headley-Lawrence
clock 29 August 2025 • 5 min read
Rural Education Matters: Olivia Shave - From tractors to lunchboxes, why farmers must help rewrite the national curriculum

Rural Education Matters: Olivia Shave - From tractors to lunchboxes, why farmers must help rewrite the national curriculum

Olivia Shave, founder of Eco Ewe and campaigner for food and farming education in schools, explains why embedding these topics onto the national curriculum is essential for public health, the environment and future generations

Olivia Shave
clock 27 August 2025 • 2 min read
OPINION: Yet another disease for farmers to contend with

OPINION: Yet another disease for farmers to contend with

This week from Farmers Guardian's livestock specialist Katie Fallon

clock 04 August 2025 • 1 min read